RIGHTS RESTRICTIONS AND DUE PROCESS

Your rights come first. Restrictions are the last resort.

We have spent a lot of time talking about our rights. We are equal to everyone else. We are equal to our friends, our families, and to staff. But sometimes our rights are restricted. Extra rules get added. People say no without a good reason. Doors get locked. Phones get taken away. That is not okay.

If we know our rights, we can notice restrictions, speak up, and fix them.

What is a rights restriction?

A rights restriction is anything that limits our freedom to use a right or make a decision. It can be big or small, short or long. It can be a rule, a staff decision, a system, a locked door, a medication, a schedule, or a missing choice.

Easy test: If other adults in the community are free to do it but we are not, it might be a restriction.

Support or restriction?

Sometimes support looks like restriction, and that can be confusing. Ask:

• Are most other adults restricted this way?
• Do we agree with the plan and understand it?
• Does it build our skills and independence, or take them away?

If the answer is no, no, and it takes skills away, it is likely a restriction.

Examples of rights restrictions

When might a restriction be okay?

Only as a last resort should any rights restriction be put in place, and only when there is a real and specific risk of serious harm to you or others, or when it is truly necessary to protect your dignity in an actual situation.

Remember the scale from the Rights and Responsibilities module? On one side are your rights. On the other side are your responsibilities, including the responsibility to keep yourself and others safe. Most of the time, the scale should stay balanced, with your rights fully respected. But in rare cases, there can be a big imbalance where a safety concern outweighs other factors. That is when a rights restriction might be needed, to steady the scale and protect you from serious harm.

Any restriction must:

• Be the least restrictive option possible
• Be time-limited. There should never be a forever restriction. 
• Include a clear plan to reduce and eventually remove it

“House rules,” “this is how we do it,” “the doctor said so,” or “it is easier for staff” are not good enough reasons. Those tip the scale for the wrong reasons, toward convenience or habit, and that is not what rights restrictions are for.

When the scale tips toward restriction, the responsibility is on the agency to prove that it is necessary, temporary, and fair, and that every creative option to keep it balanced toward freedom has been tried first.

Here is a video from Open Future Learning that talks about how agencies sometimes restrict our rights:

Due process, step by step

Staff should do every step before restricting a right.

• Name it clearly. What right is being restricted, when, where, how, and by whom.
• Include us from the start. We are at the heart of the discussion. Use plain language.
• Describe the real risk. Be specific. What could happen, how likely, how serious.
• Try support-first options. Skill building (both for people and staff), coaching, tech aids, environment changes, peer support, different staffing patterns, different times or places.
• Document every attempt. What was tried, for how long, what worked, what did not.
• Choose the least restrictive plan. Narrowly target the risk. Do not block other rights.
• Set a fade plan on day one. What needs to change to reduce or remove the restriction. Who does what. Dates and check-ins.
• Independent review. Have someone not close to the situation read the plan.
• Review often (minimum once per year). Any life change means a new look. Remove the restriction as soon as it is safe to do so.
• One right at a time. Approval for one restriction does not allow others.

Examples of avoiding restrictions with creativity

No house key because we lose keys. Try a keypad lock we can use.

Spending too fast after payday. Try a budget we choose, a low-limit card, and weekly top-ups we control.

Late-night snacks cause heartburn. Try a snack plan we make, antacid by doctor advice, and a food timer, not a locked kitchen.

Unsafe on the stove. Try an induction cooktop, visual recipes, and cooking class, not a full cooking ban.

Texting strangers online. Try online safety lessons and privacy settings we control, not a phone ban.

What to do if someone says no

Ask for the reason in plain language.

Ask to see the due process steps and the fade plan.

Ask for an independent review or a rights advisor.

If you are still not heard, follow the complaint path from Module 6, including the Fair Practices Office.

Message from the Team >